I talked to him on the interent too, he is a nice kid.I say yes, and yeah he will stick around a bit, I can tell , however I am glad he changed his name. Lol
Kracka

I'd vote yes, but I'm uncertian about him being in Red Carpet, his forum manners aren't of the best. However, dunno if that'd be exactally fair.

Overall he seems harmless enough. I think he's handled himself pretty well, under the circumstances... plays fair (usually) and is a pretty good fighter. And... well, I sorta like him.

I dunno... obviously I don't know all the facts on him. I see one thing, I hear another thing. There was one time when I did see someone under the name LordNomics was randomly swearing and insulting everyone on the server, but I really don't know if that was him or not...

It's his behavior on the forum that really drives me up the wall, it's Mano-this and Unter-that... but if you guys can handle it, good on ya and I'll shut up.

I dislike him no matter what.

"Beware the leader who bangs the drums of war in order to whip the citizenry into a patriotic fervor, for patriotism is indeed a double-edged sword.

-Julius Caesar

I can only give him a vote of yes if he proves himself worthy of it to me. If however he gets in I would strongly not allow him in Red Carpet until we see a few weeks of his behaviour as a "Minor" that word is just enough to give him a little power feed. I voted no because it is closer then a yes.

Midknight

what's in the red carpet that he shouldn't see?

just curious

Oh I don't know maybe he has a lot of friends that seem to be in another clan we kinda don't like and that his own personal friends like to fool around with his shit.

Midknight

I voted yes for the reasons that Manowar and Yellowhair gave, but I too would like it if he were unable to enter the Red Carpet (at least for a while). It's not like that's unique or anything. He'd be in the same boat as Shady.

quote:

---

what's in the red carpet that he shouldn't see?

---

For me at least, it's not that there's anything in here that he shouldn't see, it's just that it'd be nice to have a place to hide from constant nagging. Even though I'm not the one he's stalking, it's annoying to have to see that everywhere you go...

Nothing wrong with asking questions and such, but raising old moldy topics up from the grave, and posting off-topic random questions on them, that he's already repeatively asked somewhere else... is going a bit too far, in me 'umble opinion. Bad forum manners.



(ya'know, it's kinda hard to discuss this, seeing as, if he does get in here, he can read all that we say about him. I'm trying to be nice, but still... )

quote:

---

Originally posted by YellowHair:
(ya'know, it's kinda hard to discuss this, seeing as, if he does get in here, he can read all that we say about him. I'm trying to be nice, but still... )

---

That's the thing, new people should see the criticism.

I voted yes. I hate the bastard most of the time, but my elder wisdom sees some spark of hope at redemption. If he gives me usual times for him to be in the server I will volunteer to "take him under my wing" and teach him some manners, some honour, and if he wants, some of my fighting techniques. You all know how honourable I am and how much I respect such qualities. If he takes me up on the offer I expect you to treat him with the same respect that you show me. (Even you Kenshin.) Thats what I have to say. Restricted access . . . maybe. But at least let him read his criticism.

"Death before dishonour or the ignoble kill."

i voted yes to his minorship and name protection. but no to the red carpet and any member commands until he can prove maturity.
Would it be possible for a member or officer to be able to make a post that is not visible to minors?

_______________
-r0x

He has only annoyed me to no end , and the fact he dogs people about becoming a minor/member shows immaturity and overall foolishness. ( )

This is probably the toughest vote I have had to take. Reaper, as he is now doesn't seem as bad as he was as (KOD)LordKnomics, yet it is still the same person. I, out of all the members am the last to actually feel that someone is out of line or actually need to be kicked from our servers. I have been a member for a year (I joined back when we were on msn) and I have seen, in minors and members alike things that if I were in charge I would have revoked their privilages for.
I will admit it he is the first and only person I have EVER Kicked from our server. Yet despite that everyone and I mean every one should have the chance to prove their character. that is what the club is all about. Everyone here has had lapses, including myself. Does that make us any better. I don't think so. For those of us that do, REREAD our constitution and if you still can vote no in good conscience then do so. But vote as he is now not as he was.

Reaper gets a yes vote for minorship from me.

Faison

I count 4 votes with no reasons given. Fess up.

honestly i think the polls are a bit buggy, it went from 5 yes 3 no to 5 yeas 8 no in the span of like three minutes last night.

Same thing happened in Emrys' poll... you can't believe 19 people actually voted.

Ah well, it's been decided a while back that yes and no votes don't count unless someone backs it up.

... I'm not sure about that one. I'd let him grow up some.

if its 4 non counted take 2 off each.

"Beware the leader who bangs the drums of war in order to whip the citizenry into a patriotic fervor, for patriotism is indeed a double-edged sword.

-Julius Caesar

I'm sensing a large public outcry with the probable "C-Span-ification" of the Red Carpet.

I myself am abstaining from a vote because I tend to agree with some of both sides... could be good could be bad. But remember if we don't allow someone in, we'll never know if they're good or bad. Anyone can fake being a nice person for a while... but only time will tell. I would like to see a wider variety of options for voting, such as yes/no/abstain/etc... Very rarely are my gr33n friend and I polarized yes/no. We need some grey area options .